impiaaa's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 140561988 | Welcome to OSM! Please use more detail than "fix" in the changeset description--what did you change and why? For example, "Reclassified service road in SCUSD Farm." More examples here: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments Also, "unclassified road" is, confusingly, a classification, used for minor public roads. highway=unclassified I think "service road" or "track road" is better for farm roads. |
|
| 140565154 | Please make sure to save your changes in one area before moving to another, so that the changeset bounding box only covers relevant areas. |
|
| 140585962 | I think these still could have benefited from manual review. "16 Avenue Southeast Connector" is probably meant to be "16th Avenue Southeast Connector," for example, considering 16th Avenue is nearby. |
|
| 140374276 | The opening_hours in the previous version was correctly formatted, and means that it is open on Monday and Wednesday through Friday. Try the validation tool: https://openingh.openstreetmap.de/evaluation_tool/?EXP=Mo,%20We-Fr%2011:00-20:30;%20Sa-Su%2012:00-20:30 |
|
| 140374276 | Previous versions of this object said it's open on Mondays, but it looks like you changed it to be closed on Mondays. Is that correct? |
|
| 140266644 | Please use the changeset comment field to describe what you changed and why. For example, "Added speed limits from signs in street-level imagery." More examples and guidelines can be found here: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments |
|
| 140103387 | Welcome to OSM! Please use the changeset comment field to describe what you changed and why. For example, "Added a post box and adjusted a building's height." There are more examples here: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments |
|
| 139147396 | Please use the changeset comment field to describe what each change does and why. For example, "Remove a building part because it no longer exists." See this page for more examples: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments |
|
| 137897261 | Alright. amenity=place_of_worship is for entire churches, synagogues, temples, etc., and from your description and the time I visited, it seemed like these were all just divisions of the Home Church. If they all have their own services, congregations, etc., then I'll change it back. |
|
| 137897261 | amenity=place_of_worship is an inappropriate tag for individual classrooms for one church. That implies that they are all each their own church. |
|
| 138693718 | If there is no other way to tell for sure, then I guess it's okay, but I'd rather be inclined to leave it untagged. If we don't know some information then it's better to say we don't know than to take a guess. |
|
| 138693718 | I don't trust that map for the accuracy of speed limits. I've been on a few roads where it the online map is very different from the sign (like 25mph online vs 40mph irl) |
|
| 138643655 | Santa Clara LAFCO is authoritative for the boundaries of cities within Santa Clara County. It is not the authority on addresses within the cities, or roads, or anything else. |
|
| 138643655 | The import was from an authoritative data source, the City of San José. You can browse the data here: https://csj.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=3c5516412b594e79bd25c49f10fc672f |
|
| 138636690 | Anything that physically exists is valid to map, even if it's illegal or dangerous to traverse. In these cases they should be tagged with the "access" or "hazard" keys as appropriate. Otherwise someone will just add them back later. |
|
| 138643655 | You can see the history of an object by following its link and clicking "view history." In this case way/810015282/history we can see that it was from an import changeset/85987477 I also notice that the building had an address on it, which seems like valuable information to keep somewhere. |
|
| 138681808 | Please use descriptive changeset descriptions: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments The "name" field should be for the name of an object, not the route number: osm.wiki/Names I've reverted this change in changeset/138682086 |
|
| 138521986 | If an object was previously known by another name, it's helpful to put that in "old_name=*" so that people searching for the old name can still find it. |
|
| 138210897 | When improving the geometry of a feature, it's better to add and realign the existing feature than to delete and re-draw. See osm.wiki/Keep_the_history . You can add nodes to an existing way by dragging the arrow between two nodes. |
|
| 138028539 | access=no doesn't mean nobody at all can ever use it—otherwise, it wouldn't exist. It means it can't be generally used, but that can still allow for e.g. emergencies or maintenance workers. |