fortera_au's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 177630924 | Houses are assumed to be private, you can add access=private if you're concerned, but "Private Residence" as a name is just incorrect, we don't use the name tag for descriptive names, only actual names. |
|
| 177630980 | Hi, the private residence name shouldn't be added in here, that should just be drawn as a house without that as a name.
|
|
| 177630924 | Hi, adding nodes with nothing but a name isn't really ideal. I'd add a primary tag so they are actually classed as something.
|
|
| 177630722 | Hi, are these actually signed with the words "Water Tank" on them? Even if so, I don't think adding that as a name is any value, it's not a unique or distinctive name.
|
|
| 177633597 | DWG revert - revert vandalism edits from sock puppet account |
|
| 177633577 | DWG revert - revert vandalism edits from sock puppet account |
|
| 177613994 | DWG revert - revert vandalism edits from sock puppet account |
|
| 177613948 | DWG revert - revert vandalism edits from sock puppet account |
|
| 177613923 | DWG revert - revert vandalism edits from sock puppet account |
|
| 177281864 | Hi, looks like there's a typo in the house number for way/1467491633
|
|
| 177202796 | Hi there, this looks pretty good, only thing would be that if 2 and 4 Winchester Street don't share a wall, they shouldn't be joined together. If iD is wanting to snap them together, I'm happy to help fix that with JOSM or another editor.
|
|
| 177130181 | Hi, the section you've marked as service, is this just a one lane section? If so, it should probably still be residential and just tagged as a single lane.
|
|
| 177048763 | Hi, you've attached the corner of way/1465772868 to the park next to it.
|
|
| 177050198 | Hi, when you're drawing buildings, it's a good idea to click the building outline once you've drawn it, and then press Q to square it off.
|
|
| 177053624 | Hi there, for the changeset comment, it's better to describe what you're actually changing, otherwise it's not really giving any information to anyone. osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments has some good examples.
|
|
| 177069754 | Hi, the wikidata tag should use the Q ID, not the name of the item.
|
|
| 176939353 | I've fixed them up in changeset/176962528 for an example of how building=house should be drawn.
|
|
| 176847619 | Hi, since there's no physical split in the road, this shouldn't be mapped as two separate sections. Painted islands aren't counted for physical splits.
|
|
| 176551989 | I agree with JoeG, just because the terminology is American, it doesn't make the tag invalid and is commonly used in Australia. Those footway=sidewalk tags should all be restored. On the split road, that really comes down to local preference. For a small island like that I generally wouldn't bother, but it's something that might be worth a discussion in the forum to see if there's a preference one way or the other.
|
|
| 176693411 | Is "office=game development" a commonly used tag? I don't think it really is, this should probably go back to office=it, and a relevant sub-tag added if one exists.
|