The definition clearly states that it must "start at international border crossings and connect major state capitals and/or ports". The road you have marked as trunk does not fulful this criteria because it does not start at an international border crossing. It also states that trunk are defined by the Nat'l Transport Ministry, which is why I was asking for the source you used. If there is no source, then it also does not fulfuil that part of the definition. The problem here is that routing from the south on Nat'l Hwy 25 will be affected, as it would likely try to use the higher priority road (trunk on 74 and 21) over the more direct and shorter 23.

Hi, what your team's guidelines with respect to alignment to aerial imagery which is offset as is the case here? Are you using some geodata source to offset the imagery correctly or just aligning to the imagery without offsetting?

Hi, what was the reason for changing the trunk highway from the peripheral road to the road going through the city? Trunk roads are designed precisely to circumvent big cities...

Right, so this road doesn't start at an international border crossing nor does it connect to a port/harbor.

?

Hi, and welcome to OSM. Please note that taking data from Google Maps and uploading it to OSM is not permitted by their terms of service. Only upload information you have first-hand knowledge of or is otherwise open source data. Thanks & happy mapping!

Hi. Please don't align to aerial imagery without first making sure to align the images to a more precise source like an aggregated GPS layer. The roads you edited here had actually been aligned precisely to GPS tracks from Strava. Thanks & happy mapping.

Can you please provide a source for updating 72-04 and 21-03 to trunk? These are not listed as trunk roads afaik.

Hi, what was the reason ford downgrading the members of relation/5511549 to tertiary?

I've reverted your change to the ref tag. The ref on physical signs on this road has prevalence over conventions (map what's on the ground). This specific example is explicitly covered in the wiki (osm.wiki/ES:Gu%C3%ADa_para_mapear_en_Colombia#N.C3.BAmeros_de_carreteras)

Hi, and welcome to OSM. I've reviewed your changesets and found that you unfortunately deleted the northbound side of Krome Ave almost up to US 27. I've reverted the mistake and fixed accordingly. Don't hesitate to get in touch if you have any questions. Cheers & happy mapping!

Hi, what's the source for the terminal name changes please? Do you have on-the-ground knowledge that those are the names on maps, etc?

Hi and welcome to OSM! Regarding the name changes of buildings on the MIA grounds, is the numbering specific to MIA or where is this numbering coming from? There is no source tag on the changesets, so I had to ask. Also, please note that by convention, no abbreviations (e.g. Bldg) are used in OSM for names (see osm.wiki/Names#Abbreviation_.28don.27t_do_it.29). Thanks in advance and looking back to your response. Happy mapping

Hi, might I ask why the oneway tag on this way was removed? way/30018270 As far as I know this is a turning lane from the southbound Cra 43A. Thanks in advance.

Hi and thanks for your contributions. I'm curious as to the addition of addr:* tags to the roads which happened in this changeset. This is typically an error, since roads by definition define addresses and cannot therefore have one. Was this added for any particular reason? Thanks in advance.

Hi Chris, regarding the intersection at Variante Contadina, you've changed it again to a roundabout in this changeset, even though I had set it correctly twice now. This is not a roundabout as can be clearly seen here: https://www.mapillary.com/map/im/e1CiLrbE37qss2YlMiPnxA. Also, I know I'd mentioned in another one of your changesets, but by deleting roads instead of editing them, you're effectively deleting the entire history. it would be great if you could leave this valuable information in the database instead of removing it entirely. Looking forward to your response regarding the intersection.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/55252291

Bienvenido a OSM oscarito5657. Lo invito a visitar la Wiki de Colombia, especialmente la sección de clasificación de vías: osm.wiki/ES:Gu%C3%ADa_para_mapear_en_Colombia#Clasificaci.C3.B3n_de_v.C3.ADas. El uso de trunk esta reservado para carreteras troncales nacionales. He revertido la vía a terciaria. Si tiene alguna pregunta no dude en contactarme. Cordial saludo.

"Doodling" was removed in changeset/61440569.

Hi again, I'm reverting your deletions. Please help others validate your contributions by adding meaningful changeset comments (see osm.wiki/ES:Buenos_comentarios_en_conjuntos_de_cambios)

Hi and welcome to OSM. Could you help us by giving us a reason for deleting these objects? Thanks in advance!