Hi,
way/1461780422 and way/1461780423 are no horse riding centers, they may be horse riding arenas like way/1133046791. See also osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)

Danke.

Thanks for answering. I saw that you already changed it. Perhaps it is helpful for the understanding to look at an example of a riding centre that contains riding arenas (outdoor and indoor) and has a link to a website with photos, like this one:
way/1307011622#map=18/50.525509/5.455804&layers=P
https://www.lesecuriesdoksana.be/-Installations-41-.html
See also osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)

Hi,
I think way/390246009 should be tagged with leisure=sports_centre + sport=horse_racing instead of leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian. Compare osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Racecourse_(horse_racing).
(Since you are a high-ranking OSM member, I don't dare to change that myself.)

Hi,
I assume that way/1461325767 and way/1452821273 should actually be tagged in the same way as way/1444237933 and way/1444237295. Correct?

Hi,
du hast hier 3 Reitanlagen ( leisure=horse_riding ) gemappt:
way/1461499169, way/1461499170, way/1461499171.
Diese Flächen sehen aber nicht aus wie Reitanlagen ( leisure=horse_riding ).

way/1461499169 und way/1461499171 sehen aus wie Reitplätze; die sollten so getaggt werden wie z.B. way/527288284 und way/527288286.

way/1461499170 sieht aus als ob da Pferdekoppeln o.ä. ist. Die Fläche lönnte man vielleicht mit landuse=animal_keeping taggen. Es scheint mir unwahrscheinlich, dass da jemand auf den Koppeln herumreitet; also ist das alleine wohl auch keine Reitanlage. Könnte aber zu einer Reitanlage gehören. Als Reitanlage würde man einen Knoten oder die Gesamtfläche mit leisure=horse_riding mappen, wie z.B. way/941030982. Aber nicht 3 Reitanlagen, wo in Wirklichkeit nur eine ist. Vgl. osm.wiki/DE:How_to_map_a/R#Reitstall

Danke. Ich habe jetzt versucht, das im Wiki besser zu erklären ( animal=horse_walker ).

Hi,
I rhink relation/19984750 looks like a riding arena and not like a riding centre (leisure=horse_riding), similar to way/1291253239 (leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian).

Hi,
mal eine Frage zu einem etwas älteren Änderungssatz:

Du hat
way/424593254 und
way/424593255
als Führanlagen (horse_walker) gekennzeichnert, aber die sehen auf den Luftbildern nicht aus wie Führanlagen. Auf http://www.reitgemeinschaft-tegtmeyer.de/ sind auch keine Führanlagen erwähnt, sondern nur 2 Longierzirkel, womit vermutlich diese Flächen gemeint sind. Für diese ist pitch + equestrian ok. Eine Führanlage ist eine Anlage in der die Pferde automatisch (meist motorgetrieben) bewegt werden. Wäre es falsch, das animal=horse_walker von diesen Flächen zu entfernen?

Hier ist noch so eins, was nicht wie eine Führanlage aussieht:
way/1209837335

Das hier sieht aus wie eine Führanlage:
way/1222241067

@Bear-in-a-box: I just asked you to tag horse walkers with animal=horse_walker and not wirh leisure=horse_riding (horse riding centre) in changeset/176037064

Then I look forward to removing more leisure=horse_riding tags from horse walkers n the future like here:
changeset/176109937

But perhaps iD will get a preset for horse walkers:
https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/pull/1857

Hi,
two years ago we had already discussed that riding arenas and horse walkers are not horse riding centres (leisure=horse_riding):
changeset/144858869
changeset/144858341
Paddocks and small buildings are also not horse riding centres.

It seems that you forgot, because you have now tagged new ones with leisure=horse_riding again:
way/1459221854
way/1459264444
way/1459223304
way/1459222243
way/1459223143
way/1459222367
way/1459222487

It would be nice if you could correct this, because otherwise it is a bad example for others who might imitate it if they do not inform themselves in the wiki:
osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)
way/632271037/history#map=18/50.654421/4.321039&layers=P (example)

Hi,
Here you have added leisure=horse_riding to 3 areas:
way/72109824
way/72109936
way/853018125
With that you have added 3 horse riding centres to OSM, but I assume that this was not intended and that all 3 areas belong to the same horse riding centre, probably https://manegethoogt.nl/. If this assumption is correct then there should be only one area or node tagged with leisure=horse_riding for the whole riding centre, compare leisure=horse_riding#When_not_to_use
osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)
way/659541130#map=17/52.161549/5.201264&layers=P (example)

Noch nicht fertig. Aber eben angefangen: https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/pull/1857

Thanks for the quick reply.. Yes, I saw that you are relatively new to OSM. I don't want to discourage you from continuing with OSM if you enjoy it. You are by no means the only one who has used the horse_riding tag for other things, example: node/4354750993#map=19/-0.863128/-78.910625&layers=P.

Hi,
way/1456420705 and way/1456420726 are no horse riding centers / equestrian centers; they are riding arenas / rings, Arenas / rings should be tagged like way/1451542198 (leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian).

way/1456420727 is not a horse riding center / equestrian center; this area just contains 3 paddocks. It could be tagged with landuse=animal_keeping.

Compare:
osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)
way/843668144 (example)

way/1456420726 and way/1456420727 probably belong to https://www.burragesendstables.com (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3qGLYIBuBM), which could be mapped as an additional object (node or area) and tagged as a horse riding center / equestrian center (leisure=horse_riding), or as an animal boearding facility (amenity=animal_boarding).
leisure=horse_riding#When_not_to_use says: "Use this tag only once for the whole facility, don't use it multiple times on different objects belonging to it (one feature, one OSM element rule". Misuse of the tag leisure=horse_riding for arenas, paddocks, pens and other things is the reason why it is not yet rendered on the OSM "standard" map. So please avoid that.

Hi,
way/1456239137 ist wohl eher ein Reitplatz als eine Reitanlage im Sinne von osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding. Reitplatze werden normalerweise mit leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian getaggt (wozu es auch ein Preset mit dem sinnvollen Namen "Reitplatz" gibt). Vgl.
osm.wiki/DE:How_to_map_a/R#Reitstall
way/1304873173#map=18/48.765014/9.360290&layers=P (Beispiel)

Oops, this comment was meant for a different change set: changeset/175372511

Hi,
I have retagged way/1455297112 according to osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)

In JOSM you can tag riding arenas with the preset for sport=equestrian.

Hi,
I have retagged way/1455297112 according to osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)

In JOSM you can tag riding arenas with the preset for sport=equestrian.