OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
169960455

Hi,
wieso hast du die Fläche umgetaggt. Das ist doch ein Reitplatz - oder? Und die Fläche war vorher so getaggt wie Reitplätze in OSM normalerweise getaggt werden. Vgl.
osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding
osm.wiki/DE_talk:Tag:leisure=horse_riding#reitplatz_vs_reitanlage

169915031

Hi,
The tag leisure=horse_riding should be used for the whole area of the equestrian centre and not for one of its buildings; see
osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)
way/1414612042#map=18/46.733952/1.837926&layers=P (example)

169636333

Hi,
way/1418167832 ist ein Reitplatz und keine Reitanlage, sollte mit leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian statt leisure=horse_riding getaggt werden (siehe Wiki).
Der passende Preset ist in JOSM leider nicht einfach zu finden wenn man nach "reit" sucht, aber man kann nach "pferd" suchen und dann den Preset für "Pferdesport" auswählen.

169605689

Hi,
way/1418035262 and
way/1418005081 and
way/1416618883 are no horse riding centres (as explained on leisure=horse_riding), they are horse riding arenas and should be tagged with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian like
way/1026068321

Compare former discussion
changeset/147811585

169583397

Hi,
leisure=horse_riding is not the right tag for a rodeo arena (see wiki description). Here is a better example:
way/451864400

169493278

Hi,
way/1417532791 does not really look like a horse riding centre. Did you want to map a circular way for horse riding? In this case leisure=track + sport=equestrian would have been more approriate; leisure=horse_riding is not intended for linear objects; see leisure=horse_riding

169331601

Hi,
way/465980657 und way/142708615 sind keine Reitanlagen, das sind irgendwelche Gebäude (Führanlage?, Longierhalle?), deshalb waren sie mit building=yes getaggt und du hast sie auf leisure=horse_riding (Reitanlage) umgetaggt. Ohne ein building=* Tag werden sie nicht mehr als Gebäude auf der Karte dargestellt.

Beispieö für eine Reitanlage:
way/117203231
Vgl.
osm.wiki/DE:How_to_map_a/R#Reitstall

169315125

Hi,
way/1416618883 is a very similar case to the one we discussed in changeset/147811585.

169295593

The 4 rectangular areas near that node which are probably the riding arenas of that center, are also not racetracks; riding arenas are usually tagged with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian (not sport=horse_racing), and iD has a preset for that. Example: way/345745923

169295593

Hi,
this looks more like an equestrian center than a horse racetrack; compare osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)

169287787

Hi,
you have removed building=yes from way/184714968 and replaced it by leisure=horse_riding + name=Les Ecuries de Lussat. And you have added node/13017140267 also with leisure=horse_riding + name=Les Ecuries de Lussat.
Now this Les Ecuries de Lussat is mapped twice and the building is no longer rendered as a building on the map. I propose to revert the tagging of the building; this will fix both issues.
Here is an example from not far away: node/12756686338#map=18/46.221376/2.212197&layers=P

Traduction automatique :

Bonjour,
vous avez supprimé building=yes de way/184714968 et l'avez remplacé par leisure=horse_riding + name=Les Ecuries de Lussat. Et vous avez ajouté node/13017140267 également avec leisure=horse_riding + name=Les Ecuries de Lussat.
Maintenant, Les Ecuries de Lussat est cartographié deux fois et le bâtiment n'est plus rendu comme un bâtiment sur la carte. Je propose d'inverser le balisage du bâtiment, ce qui résoudra les deux problèmes.
Voici un exemple non loin de là : node/12756686338#map=18/46.221376/2.212197&layers=P

Traduit avec DeepL.com (version gratuite)

169022625

Ich habe es auf horse_riding geändert und sonst noch etwas ergänzt / verbessert so wie mir das nach Luftbild möglich erschien. Kannst es ja irgendwann kontrollieren / korrigieren.

169165529

Hi,
it looks like you have split one riding centre into four here:
way/1392097834
way/1415929062
way/1415929063
way/1415929064
I don't think this was a good idea. As explained on the wiki page for the leisure=horse_riding tag, this tag should be used for the entire riding centre once and not for all the objects that belong to it. What you have mapped now and tagged with leisure=horse_riding looks like riding arenas and round pens (https://www.jhrc.co.jp/images/gallery1.jpg) and should be tagged with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian instead of leisure=horse_riding.
Compare
osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)
way/580524439#map=18/35.986371/139.617027&layers=P (example)

In JOSM you can use the preset for sport=equestrian to tag riding arenas.

169022625

Hi,
way/324457236/history ist aber ein großer hot_tub geworden! Hast du dich da evtl. vertippt?

169015783

It is ok now. Thanks.

169015783

Hi,
this is not a good way to map a horse riding centre (Senante en Selle); it should be mapped once as a separate object (node or area), not different parts of it all as horse riding centres. way/1415178940 is not a horse riding centre; it is a horse riding arena like way/1415158837 and should be tagged with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian. way/499726098 is also not a horse riding centre; it is just a small building which belongs to the horse riding centre; but since you have removed the tag building=yes it is no longer rendered as a building.
See also:
osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)
way/1126769842#map=19/48.815908/1.956528&layers=P (example)

Traduction automatique :

Hi,
ce n'est pas une bonne façon de cartographier un centre équestre (Senante en Selle) ; il devrait être cartographié une fois en tant qu'objet séparé (noeud ou zone), et non pas différentes parties en tant que centres équestres. way/1415178940 n'est pas un centre équestre ; c'est un manège comme way/1415158837 et devrait être étiqueté avec leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian. way/499726098 n'est pas non plus un centre équestre ; c'est juste un petit bâtiment qui appartient au centre équestre ; mais depuis que vous avez enlevé l'étiquette building=yes, il n'est plus cartographié en tant que bâtiment.
Voir aussi :
osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(équestre)
way/1126769842#map=19/48.815908/1.956528&layers=P (exemple)

Traduit avec DeepL.com (version gratuite)

168717933

Na klar. Bei OSM ist ja sowieso alles freiwillig.

168898285

Hi,
I think that a trailhead is not a trail riding station and especially not an equestrian center (leisure=horse_riding) as it is described in the wiki. Here is an example of an equestrian centre:
way/1228517621#map=17/47.747602/-122.142085&layers=P

There is a tag for trailheads (highway=trailhead, used ~15k x), Wouldn't that be more appropriate for a trailhead?

168820181

Hi,
relation/19345794 does not look like a horse riding arena (leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian) and way/1412930874 does not look like an equestrian centre; the whole thing is probably this small racecourse: http://murotaht.web.fc2.com/
Compare
osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Racecourse_(horse_racing)
way/571204779 (example)

168752373

Hi,
node node/12992811159 correctly represents a riding center (www.thejranch.com), this is ok.
But all the areas that you have mapped and tagged with leisure=horse_riding or leisure=track + sport=horse_racing
way/1413866410 (leisure=horse_riding)
way/1413866413 (leisure=horse_riding)
way/1413866416 (leisure=track + sport=horse_racing)
way/1413866448 (leisure=horse_riding)
don't look like riding centers (leisure=horse_riding) or horse racetracks (leisure=track + sport=horse_racing). They look more like riding arenas (in this case should be tagged with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian) or something else.

For riding arenas there is a different preset; examples:
way/1282657309
way/1282657310

Related information:
osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)
osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Racecourse_(horse_racing)
osm.org/#map=19/37.661079/-97.187100&layers=P (example)