Hufkratzer's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 126275499 | Hi, way/889162588 looks like a riding arena (see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena) in the aerial view, but you have tagged it with leisure=horse_riding, which is for complete riding centres (see leisure=horse_riding). |
|
| 126067726 | Hi, way/1093689935 is tagged with leisure=horse_riding, but it is just a building and not a riding center. There seems to be a riding arena and a round pen next to this building and all this probably belongs to the area which may be tagged with leisure=horse_riding (see leisure=horse_riding). leisure=horse_riding would probably also be appropriate on way/601963252 which you tagged as pitch 4 years ago. |
|
| 125983199 | Hi, if way/1093158683 is a racecourse it should rather be tagged with leisure=sports_centre + sport?equestrian, compare leisure=horse_riding#Tagging |
|
| 125970895 | Hi, was du da als Reitsportanlage gemappt und mit leisure=horse_riding getaggt hast ist nur die Reithalle von der Reitsportanlage, die Anlage selbst ist ja größer. Das sollte besser auch so gemappt werden. vgl.
|
|
| 125925023 | Hi, way/1092778018 looks like a round pen; these are usually tagged like small riding arenas (see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena), but you have tagged them with leisure=horse_riding, which is for complete riding centres (see leisure=horse_riding). |
|
| 125624499 | Then I see 2 possibilities for the old roofed area that could make sense:
|
|
| 125578343 | Hi, why did you tag way/1090555830 with leisure=horse_riding and way/1090555831 with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian ? In Bing way/1090555830 looks like a jumping arena. If this is true it should also be tagged with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian, see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena. Tag leisure=horse_riding could rather be used for the area of the whole Club Hípico, but this is already tagged as park. Furthermore, way/1090555832 seems to be quite small for sport=horse_racing, but I don't know what that is. |
|
| 125574770 | If way/1090536661 is a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Round_pen the usual OSM tagging would be like for riding arenas, see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena. |
|
| 125624499 | Hi, you have removed building=stable from way/871818122 and replaced it with leisure=horse_riding. I am not sure if this was intended because this object looks like a building in bing. Also the horse_riding tag seems inappropriate for such a small area, it is for the whole area of the ranch (see leisure=horse_ridin), so the area tagged with leisure=horse_ridng should probably at least also contain the stable way/1090822981 (or set a node). For riding arenas see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena. |
|
| 125650948 | Hi, you have removed the building tag from way/31898888 and replaced it with leisure=horse_riding. This object looks like a building in the aerial view, therefore I assume it was not intended to remove the building tag. Furthwemore, the horse_riding tag is for the whole area of the facility and not for just one building, see leisure=horse_riding. If this building is a riding hall / indoor arena consider using tag building=riding_hall instead. |
|
| 125416426 | It is ok then and dosn't need to be changed. If in iD you search for "riding ring" you get the preset with name "Horseback Riding Arena" which adds the tags leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian. |
|
| 125416426 | I'm not sure I understand this completely. Don't you think this area should be called "arena"? Compare https://www.arenas.ebarrelracing.com/ohio/wb-ranch-and-arena-swanton-oh/ |
|
| 125416426 | last link fixed: osm.org/query?#map=17/40.73315/-77.93085 |
|
| 125416426 | ||
| 125416426 | The difference between leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian and leisure=horse_riding is not that one is for practice or warn up and the other for competition. The difference is that leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian is for just the riding areas and leisure=horse_riding is for the whole facility including stables and other stuff, see leisure=horse_riding and way/916315775 |
|
| 125312405 | Erledigt, s. changeset/125586936 |
|
| 125324841 | Thanks, I also corrected these old ones: changeset/125563663 |
|
| 125312405 | Hi, du hast hier building=shed durch leisure=horse_riding ersetzt. Auf dem Luftbild sieht es aber so aus, als ob das Gebäude noch da ist. Wenn das so ist, wäre ein building-Tag nach wie vor sinnvoll. (Gilt auch für way/80338466).
|
|
| 125394398 | Hi, I think way/1065076254 looks like a riding arena (see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena) in the aerial view, but you have tagged it with leisure=horse_riding, which is for complete riding centres (see leisure=horse_riding). |
|
| 125319305 | It seems the site "Old Spanish Trail Arena" is an area much larger than just this building, see
|