OpenStreetMap
CurlingMan13's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 159114770 | As I had commented before, only features that currently exist should be mapped. Features that no longer exist should not be mapped on OSM, and should instead be mapped on OHM (OpenHistoricalMap). I tried to engage previously, but was met with hostility and antagonism (referring to your profile page). You have reverted changesets nilly-willy, without checking that the features removed were actually overbuilt and replaced. And in the process of your careless reverts, you have removed many valid additions, including new railways, new buildings, landuses, etc. Again, I can't stress this enough, OSM is only for what *currently* exists and can be verified, not for what once exists. I have asked you to stop adding (or readding) features that no longer exist and have been built over/replaced and to cease the hasty deletion/reverts of new features that have been verified. osm.wiki/Good_practice#:~:text=Do%20not%20map%20objects%20if%20they%20do%20not%20exist%20currently |
|
| 159094081 | Changeset reverted. We use access tags to denote private property.
|
|
| 159094112 | Changeset reverted. We use access tags to denote private property.
|
|
| 159098587 | Looks like I'm your first edit review. Allow me to mark your first changeset as "Good". Keep up the good work, and always happy to see your contributions.
|
|
| 159108707 | Changeset reverted. We use access tags to denote private property.
|
|
| 159027381 | Ah, gotcha. Thanks Allison! Rand 88 - when you submit a changeset, please use a changeset comment to describe or state what you did. For example "Added roads in woods from aerial imagery" helps immensely when reviewing OSM edits. Thanks, and see you around. -CurlingMan13 |
|
| 159039195 | Changeset reverted. Access tags should be used instead. Read more here:
|
|
| 159027381 | What do you mean when you say "Not reported" ?
|
|
| 153641717 | What source did you use for the new businesses? |
|
| 158987055 | You should also add this tag to this porta potty if it is moble, like rent-a-toilet. |
|
| 158839349 | No problem, and welcome to OSM! Also, you can do more than one edit in a changeset. So instead of just adding one business, you can do 10 or 20. Just make sure you submit your changesets before you go to the other side of the world. Keep up the good work and let me know if you have any questions. You're learning quick. |
|
| 158623205 | Hello. I noticed you have been going back and forth wit this user. Did you ever report them to the DWG? They keep doing it and just did it again. Thanks. |
|
| 158826372 | Was the path completely removed?
|
|
| 158839349 | "Q" can be used to square buildings and give them square angles.
|
|
| 158838310 | Welcome to OSM! Looks like you corrected the errors in your second changeset. Don't forget to close the notes after adding the business. |
|
| 158832936 | This chamgeset has been reverted. On OSM, we map all roads and features, private or not, then use tags to designate/control access. You can read more on why deletion is not the answer here: osm.wiki/Why_we_won%27t_delete_roads_on_private_property We also don't control where ubereats, UPS, USPS, GrubHub, etc. drive. |
|
| 158829923 | Hello, couple comments. 1) Please upload/submit changes before changing continents or otherwise geographicallu seperated areas. 2) Please use a more detailed changeset comment. If you forgot, then submit the changesets with fewer edits. 3) Names are only a name and not a description. "random concrete thing" is a description, not a name. This "name" should be removed. 4) What's up with adding random islets? There are better tags that should be used.
|
|
| 158749167 | Changeset reverted. You deleted roads and other buildings which clearly exist. |
|
| 158665238 | Good edit. FYI - can make more than one change in each changeset. :D
|
|
| 158665586 | When manipulating areas, there are a couple hotkeys you can use for a better quality edit. For example, "Q" can be used to give it right angles and "square" the angles. You can also square it up by right clicking the area and selecting the square. Once you master that, you can even try pushing "O" instead. ;)
|