Carnildo's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 99703240 | Please don't just scribble out buildings. It takes hours to clean them up. |
|
| 99620969 | Is there a reason why you tagged a section of WA-206 as "primary"? The usual convention is that state routes are tagged as "secondary" unless they're particularly significant or particularly minor (and WA-206 is verging on "particularly minor"). |
|
| 99659328 | It's also not how they're labeled on the signposts -- it's just a bare campsite number. |
|
| 99654171 | The Specimen Ridge trail doesn't have a bridge across the Lamar River, either. |
|
| 99654575 | If the editor is telling you about a path that's crossing a river, don't just click the "add a bridge" button to make it go away. There very much isn't a bridge across Slough Creek at the spot you added one. |
|
| 99649743 | Where are you getting the bridges on the Pelican Valley trail from? Aerial imagery doesn't show them. |
|
| 99608299 | Why on Earth did you delete the Grand Prismatic Spring overlook? |
|
| 99542282 | That map says it's based on OpenStreetMap. |
|
| 99606447 | Liberty Cap isn't a mountain peak, it's a rock formation. |
|
| 99542282 | I know for sure that "Canyon Campground road" is wrong, and I'm reasonably sure the rest of the names are as well. (Source: my parents spent a season working at Canyon Campground.) I'll be reverting the batch. |
|
| 99654959 | I've reverted this changeset. |
|
| 99654959 | I added those because I hiked them and have GPS traces showing the routing. OSM isn't supposed to be a copy of various official maps, it's supposed to be the result of looking at what's actually there. Just because something isn't on an official map isn't a reason to delete it. |
|
| 99654959 | As far as I can tell, the paths you deleted still exist. Why did you delete them? |
|
| 99239930 | Where did you get this name from? The BC government has some very different names for this section of highway. |
|
| 99263025 | The most common way to map a business inside a building is to add a point with the business information; a more detailed method is the Simple Indoor Tagging scheme: osm.wiki/Simple_Indoor_Tagging Drawing one building over another just confuses everyone involved. |
|
| 99019047 | I don't think an access of "permissive" is correct for something that's in a public park. |
|
| 98923401 | When you divide a road like you did at the intersection of Lancaster and US-95, please make sure you update the lane counts and move the traffic signals to the new intersection points. |
|
| 98870660 | How about we call it the "Elko-Roosville Highway", since that's what the BC government seems to call it: https://web.archive.org/web/20170105151258/http://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/transportation/transportation-reports-and-reference/numbered-routes# |
|
| 98658241 | The section between Revere Road and Imbler Creek is packed fine gravel. I don't know what it's like any further west than that. |
|
| 98724340 | Is US-2 physically divided here? Recent imagery isn't sharp enough to show something like a median barrier. If it isn't, then please don't map it as such -- with a pair of ways, there's nowhere to put the center turn lane that's visible in older imagery. |