Carnildo's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 93814576 | Negative layer numbers are traditionally used for underground objects. If the editor is warning you about a sidewalk crossing a roof-only building, the correct fix is to put the roof on layer 1, not to put the sidewalk on layer -1. |
|
| 93759468 | As far as I can tell, the "car wash" you added is a defunct car wash with a building still prominently labeled "Car Wash" with an equally prominent "Car Wash" sign out front. |
|
| 93724956 | When you're tracing buildings, please square your corners (select the building and hit the "Q" key). It makes for much nicer-looking outlines. |
|
| 93556990 | Thanks. That'd been bothering me for a while, but I hadn't been able to get up there to check things out. |
|
| 93534425 | I've reverted this changeset. There's been some recent construction in the area, and even the latest imagery is outdated. |
|
| 93515210 | Please don't do huge edits like this. It's not showing up properly in any of the QA tools, so it's impossible to tell if there are any mistakes. |
|
| 93492524 | Is there a reason why you turned a religious school into a church? |
|
| 93446122 | I noticed you added a bunch of nodes with nothing but an elevation tag. Was this intentional? |
|
| 93419786 | In my survey notes, I described it as "a bridge or tunnel" in the area of a golf course. Judging from the aerial imagery, it's a culvert-style tunnel containing either a service road or a golf cart path connecting two halves of a golf course. In the western United States, a common way of grade-separating a major highway and a minor road is to run the road through a large-diameter culvert. It's faster, cheaper, and easier to maintain than either a concrete tunnel or a bridge. |
|
| 93419786 | Is there a reason why you deleted the road? |
|
| 93399781 | Could you please use more descriptive changeset comments? It makes it easier to figure out what you're trying to do. |
|
| 93030929 | Is there a reason you deleted a bunch of sidewalks and the Kalispell Police Department? |
|
| 92841662 | Is Meridian Road really one-way over its full length? The road markings don't look correct for that. |
|
| 92784726 | Official maintenance isn't the only reason to call something "not a track". If it can be easily driven by an ordinary car, rather than requiring something high-clearance, I'd call it "minor/unclassified" at least to the turnoff of the Rocky Lake boat launch. |
|
| 92784726 | Rocky Lake Road looks like a fairly substantial road in the aerial imagery. Are you sure it's a track and not a regular road? |
|
| 92733599 | Could you please pay more attention to what the AI is telling you to do? By my count, this changeset mapped: 1) A building that was actually three buildings, 2) A building overlapping a parking lot, 3) A building that was demolished about five years ago, 4) A building that was actually two buildings, and 5) Two buildings that only vaguely resembled the actual structures. |
|
| 92733599 | Please be more careful when you're adding buildings. In particular, this building (way/860887050) was already on the map as "recently demolished". |
|
| 92663587 | Are you sure about the routing of Bacon Loop Trail? When I hiked it about a decade and a half ago, it had just (as in, earlier that week) been re-routed away from Bean Creek, and no longer followed the lines on the topo map. |
|
| 92608003 | When you're moving business information to building outlines like you did here, could you please make sure you don't delete address information in the process? |
|
| 92440704 | Generally the only reason to map individual units as separate outlines is if they're physically independent -- you could knock one down and the others would stay standing. That's usually quite obvious from looking at the roof, and the roof of this building is just as clearly a single piece. Addressing of individual units within a building can be handled just fine with address nodes. A good example of the "physically independent" situation would be this section of Sprague: osm.org/#map=19/47.65705/-117.38177 |