Hi,

Thanks for contributing to OpenStreetMap.

In this changeset, you deleted this bit of road (way/1126557590/history). Is there actually not a road here, or was this by accident? Currently there are gaps in these bus route relations due to this changeset:

relation/10736859#map=19/-37.77134/144.96213
relation/5758780#map=18/-37.77134/144.96190

If it was done in error then this changeset would need to be partially reverted (and I don't know how to do that)

Hi ChonkerStonker,

This changeset added also caused issues with bus route relations. The newly made ways were added at the end of the route relations and you didn't sanitise for which direction the bus is meant to go in, so each bus route was going in either direction of the road for each roundabout.

Also, Highview Road (28640412) (way/28640412/history) should have been split in two from where it meet with Chesterville Road to properly allow for routes to turn left without going on the wrong side of the road. You can see what I mean here (way/1305487927) with what I did.

I've since fixed the routing in changeset/154794621 as well as splitting the road to allow for turning.

You should be able to see both bus routes following their respective correct paths here:
relation/2747625#map=18/-37.93026/145.06435
relation/11189472#map=18/-37.93026/145.06435

I know that this changeset was made before my first comments, but I've fixed at least 2 separate routes today that had issues caused by your edits. This changeset: changeset/153021217 being another one that had issues with the routes, fixed here: changeset/154794427. Just want you to be aware.

Please don't hesitate to reach out for assistance when it comes to routes!

Hi ChonkerStonker,

A bit nick-picky here, but, in this changeset you added the newly created Burlington Street ways to relation/8981021/history/81 at the end instead of in order. This makes it look like the bus "teleports" to the way after completing its route if you follow it in order. You also left the original ways from the other side of the road which that route doesn't go on, unless the bus actually travels on the right side of the road for roundabouts. I'm not sure if iD shows any warnings for this, but they appear as "Gap in route" errors on JOSMe and a few other tools. There were similar issues with relation/8981020/history/98 as well as some of your other changesets editing relations.

I've since fixed those routes in changeset/154758391 by removing the ways from the wrong side of the road and by reordering the ways placed at the end of the relation.

When editing bus route relations, please confirm that the bus routes are on the correct side of the road and are in order :)

Hopefully pointing this out to you is helpful and you know what to look out for now, but if what I said doesn't make much sense please let me know and I'll try and explain it better!

Thanks for all your contributions and have fun mapping!

Hi ChonkerStonker,

Just letting you know that both bus route relations you edited in this changeset had members on Ayr Street in the wrong order (wrongly put at the end of the relation) as well as a few gaps. I've since fixed those issues in changeset/154714567 and changeset/154714525.

No worries!

Hi,

Thank you for contributing to Open Street Map. Just commenting to let you know that I've changed the carpark way/909282332 roughly back to what it was. This is because the Bing Imagery for it is very out of date and doesn't accurately reflect what it looks like at the moment. The Esri World Imagery seems to be much more recent, especially when you zoom out with it. What I normally do is switch between the two imageries to make sure that nothing major has changed between them. Hope that helps!

Happy mapping!